Napoleonic, WSS & ECW wargaming, with a load of old Hooptedoodle on this & that


Monday 13 August 2018

Handicrafts Dept - Sow's Ear Research Project

My recent introduction to Picquet's "Field of Battle" rules has got me thinking of all sorts of issues beyond merely playing the game. I've grown very used to Commands & Colors type games, where the presentation of units and the associated information is very simple - I've developed a big stock of sabots, on which the units are fixed magnetically. Since the game is simple (by design), it is possible to get away with placing a few coloured counters on the sabots to denote losses - it doesn't add greatly to the visual delights, but it's not a big problem.

FoB is a bit different - the units change formation, so sabots are out, and a fair amount of information needs to be associated with each unit. I really can't be doing with roster sheets - personally, given the state of my eyesight, I find them very hard work - constantly focusing and re-focusing between the sheet and the action on the table is fatiguing, as is constantly howking the specs off and on (and losing the beggars behind The Ridge). It is easy to add a few extra colours of counters with defined meanings, but the fundamental principles of OWL (the OCD Wargamers' League,  of which I am a founder member) argue strongly against running the risk of reducing the game to a pigs' breakfast.

I've been thinking up some way of making a neat and tidy job of keeping everything I need to know about each unit, right on the tabletop.

Yesterday I had a lot of fun with a bag of MDF strips and some laser-cut dice frames, suitable for 5mm dice. I think I have developed a working design. Still a couple of things to think about, and then it should just be a question of making about 100 of these things.

Dice frames from Supreme Littleness Designs, suitable for 5mm minidice, a pile
of 50mm x 10mm MDF bases from
East Riding Minatures, and a pack of 200
5mm mini-dice from
The Dice Shop - that's my starter
Sticky PVA glue the bits into position, a coat of baseboard paint...
...and I have a roll of 10mm wide self-adhesive magnetic compound strip, plus
some experimental sheets of plain (non-adhesive) magnetic sheet
My units are on MDF subunit bases, which have magnetic sheet stuck underneath, and
they sit on sabots which are topped with steel paper (or whatever the modern
replacement for steel paper is called).
My subunit bases are 50mm wide x 45mm deep; I add a loose underlay of plain mag
sheet underneath one of the subunits - this underlay is 50mm wide x 55mm deep,
which will allow me to attach a 10mm deep info tray behind the troops. 
Attach the magnetic adhesive tape underneath the info tray, trim with scissors to
smarten it up a bit - you can see where it will attach behind the subunit base...
...and here is the modified set-up on the sabot - no actual information on the tray
yet. Note that this is all completely temporary - I can remove the info tray and the
underlay and everything is back as it was.
In a FoB context, here's the same unit deployed into line - the underlay is still under the left hand subunit, 
and the magnetised info tray will hold in place (reasonably well, anyway) for movement around the battlefield. 
Here the tray is equipped with a minidice (to record loss of what FoB calls "Unit Integrity"), with a laminated
label showing the fighting and defensive dice sizes applicable to this unit, and a coloured cube to indicate which
Combat Group (= brigade) this battalion belongs to. My 8mm wooden cubes, which seemed pleasingly small
and neat, now seem maybe a tad big and clumsy - I might replace them, but this gets me operational for the
moment.
The big experiment in this lot was to see whether the existing magnetised bases, sitting on the magnetic underlay, sitting on the steel paper on the sabots, would attach as firmly as the original rig without the underlay. The answer is "not quite", but it's good enough for tabletop use - probably not secure enough for transporting them in the car. The underlays and info trays can travel separately from the troops!

Righto - it works. Fire up the factory, and get a stack of them made up, painted, labelled and stored away for forthcoming battles. OWL in action.

16 comments:

  1. Bravo - I did something vaguely similar with my AWI troops, as DG always complains about having to refer to OOB sheets as well.. having done it I would say he was right... :o)

    http://steve-the-wargamer.blogspot.com/2016/07/awi-re-basing-project.html

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I did see your post from 2 years ago - that was one of a series of drip-feed influences that turned me from disliking the idea of using little dice as indicators to an acceptance that it might be a practicable approach. My bursts of infrastructure fiddly bits are always just that - bursts. Recently someone was being complimentary about my magnetic basing/sabot arrangements, and I had to explain that - like a number of other features of my games - it came from many years of frustration and an eventual (overdue) blockbuster project to sort it out.

      Delete
  2. You are a genius sir! I look forward to pushing the troops around with their new tails shortly.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Maybe not a genius [blushes] - just rather a slow, though dogged, learner. The troops are demanding your next visit - they speak of little else.

      Delete
  3. Only those who do not understand OCD fail to realize its creative power and potential. Your effort is no exception. Excellent solution!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Jon - I had a less sincere response from Martin S, who couldn't understand why OWL might be an acronym for Old Dyslexic Leg-warmers. If I get a good reaction to posts about my fiddling around with glue and magnets in pursuit of increased efficiency, I might be tempted to run a short series on my filing and storage systems - that should kill off the surviving readership.

      For example - I keep most of my Napoleonic troops in an old bookcase, on their sabots, in something very close to OOB order, so that I can simply relocate adjacent groups of units from the shelves to the battlefield and - since I don't remove casualties - slot them back again, quickly and simply, when it's time to tidy up. Visiting generals often display a sort of faintly shocked amusement, somewhere between admiration and disbelief.

      Delete
  4. Ooooh, this is good stuff. Watching development with great interest.
    I may have to make the red pom-poms redundant.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Bonjour, Monsieur le Duc. At present, though I haven't yet bought any, there is a strong possibility that some mini pom-poms will still be required - for OOC and routers, as in your own games. I'm still thinking about this - the trays will at least give an official location for the pom-poms - my concerns about them are mostly in the area of the mess I could generate by dropping the things in action (or sneezing, which is a risk in the pollen season). As things stand, the pom-poms are still in the prototype...

      Delete
  5. I believe that the historical solution to this sort of thing was to appoint a staff to supply you with information when needed however, this looks like a pretty good alternative.

    If I could focus on something for more than a week, something like this might be useful. I have in the past attempted to use illegible hand painted labels to assist me, didn't work so well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hand painted labels are fine - if I didn't feel actual pain when I see my own hand-painting I would regard that as an elegant, traditional approach. This is all along what I perceive as the right direction. Napoleon (for example) had a frightening depth of staff record-keeping to call upon, but in action he could also recognise the 9eme Léger when he saw them, and he had a good idea how they were doing without looking for his reading glasses. My little trays I consider as something of a necessary evil, but they beat the bejesus out of typed lists and wall charts when you are short sighted.

      Delete
  6. Very good. I did a few test bases with 7mm frames and dice and found the dice sat too deeply in the frame for by banana fingers to easily pick them up. I have since bought some 10mm dice and frames to experiment with, but they look huge by comparison.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The 5mm dice are very small, but they just pass the visibility test. Michael at Supreme Littleness does very skinny dice frames. I had considered just using minidice without the frames, but I know they would just finish up in dark corners of the room. Napoleon would not go for this.

      Delete
  7. Looks great! Colored beads could be used to designate the command group.
    How about "out of command" status? We use "chickens" (generic for all manner of domestic and non domestic critters). If nothing else, they make great fodder for bad puns etc. :-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you sir - I have a bad track record with small objects on the battlefield - especially rolly and droppy objects. Hence the appeal of the dice frames. I am still looking for some kind of markers for OOC and routing units - it may turn out to be 8mm coloured pom-poms (I can buy a bag of a 1000 from China for less than £2 - I have to think carefully about that - no wonder our economy is shot...) - pom-poms can fly about in a stiff breeze, and can certainly be dropped in moments of stress, but they are soft enough to cut down on the rolling - my flock-free basing system doesn't help a lot here. I'm still thinking about this. Brent's own suggestions for on-the-fly record-keeping systems are a bit tentative - slightly unruly alignment of bases to denote OOC would not work for me (because I'd keep straightening them, without thinking) and spotting the units which are routing (i.e. facing the wrong way) without some form of helpful little marker might also be suboptimal. Head scratching continues.

      Delete
  8. A very neat solution. I am still using the clear plastic shower curtain rings as casualty markers, although they are often difficult to see. Sometimes when I deploy my troops into the field I find casualty markers from their previous action. Very bad for morale!

    ReplyDelete