Napoleonic, WSS & ECW wargaming, with a load of old Hooptedoodle on this & that


Monday, 31 March 2025

Hooptedoodle #476 - Macdonald Road Library (Leith Walk, Edinburgh)

 I read recently that the public library in Macdonald Road was 120 years old last year - I confess that I was rather surprised to learn that it is still open; Leith is well out of my usual stomping ground these days, and public libraries are not doing too well, I fear, since Google has made it unfashionable to actually know anything.

Why mention it, then?

Well, back in the early 1970s I had a fleeting acquaintance with the old place - bear with me, and I shall attempt to explain in a pleasantly businesslike manner...

 
Appropriate monochrome photo of the library in 1930 - note the tram cars in Leith Walk. For some reason, my memories of Edinburgh in the early 1970s seem to be monochrome as well - maybe it was that sort of place
 
 
I think that military and wargaming books were indexed under code U - not that I wasted my study time with such matters, of course

Back in those days I was working as an actuarial trainee with a big (old) insurance company in Edinburgh, and part of the deal was that I got two half-day study periods a week during the winter (90 minutes each, in fact), which I had to take in the designated study room, in the attic above Accounts, which was filthy and unheated, and my recollection is that most of the students chain-smoked. Grim.

One winter my department moved. This sort of thing didn't happen often at the time, but the company's group pensions business was expanding quickly, and some of the pensions departments were relocated to a new building, in Leith, a good distance from the main offices in George Street. If the mention of a new building sounds promising, it must be borne in mind that the building in question had been built as an investment, but the proposed new occupant (Scottish Gas, I think) disliked it so much that they ducked the contract, so my employer cut their losses by using it themselves; it was probably good enough for us peasants in Pensions, anyway.

I now had an additional snag in that my twice a week study periods would be on the other end of a 30-minute journey each way. I made the mistake of asking the Personnel people if some other arrangement might be possible, and contempt was served up from a great height. If I chose not to use the facilities which were so generously offered, then that was my problem, etc etc.

As it happened, my boss was a nice old guy, and I agreed with him informally that I could absent myself on Tuesday mornings, and spend 3 hours in Macdonald Road library, which was only a few minutes away.

This worked well. The library was large, and very quiet indeed, and my 3 hour visits were much better for serious studying than the filth-hole up in George Street. I was surprised how deserted the place was - there were 3, sometimes 4, pensioners who came in to keep warm in the cold weather, otherwise there was very little happening. Maybe it was crowded in the evenings.

One of the pensioners was always very busy, scribbling away - the others seemed to sleep most of the time.

Eventually I struck up a nodding-terms relationship with the librarian in charge - Miss Gilhooley, who was a rather timid-looking young lady - pale, with red hair - and sometimes she would offer to make an extra cup of tea for me. This was kindness of a sort that actuarial trainees were not used to.

It turned out that Miss Gilhooley lived somewhere on the South Side, as did I, and on one occasion she sat next to me on the morning bus into the city. I learned a little of daily goings-on at Macdonald Road. It seems that the pensioner who did all the writing was a Mr Duguid [I have no idea how or why I remember this stuff], and what he liked to do was to bring in a ballpoint pen, and fill in all the letters o, e, a, b, d, p, q (etc) in the library's public copy of the Scotsman newspaper - he also liked to draw spectacles on the photographs of people in the news. I am pleased to add that as far as I know he didn't do anything worse than this, but what he did was relentless - he worked at it for most of the day. Miss Gilhooley used a cunning plan, and would lay out an old newspaper for Mr Duguid's use, but this didn't work, since one of his companions could read (Mr Duguid could not), and tipped hm off that it was not today's edition. Mr Duguid refused (quite correctly) to waste his effort destroying an out-of-date newspaper, so a Plan B came into use. Miss Gilhooley did a very brave, unofficial thing, and ordered a special second copy of the Scotsman for Mr Duguid. This seemed to be working, though the auditors would no doubt find out eventually.

Miss Gilhooley's worst experience had been a morning when another elderly chap came in, but he was wearing a Rangers FC scarf. This caused an actual punch-up with the regulars - Macdonald Road is right in Hibernians territory - and Miss Gilhooley had not witnessed hooliganism of this sort before or since. The only casualty was the maintenance man, who was struck with a fire extinguisher - or claimed he had been.

As I recall, my visits to the library only lasted for one winter. I can't remember why, but I know that you didn't get study time if you had to resit an exam failure, so maybe there is a clue in there somewhere.

Lovely city, Edinburgh, but I have a strong memory of it being a cold, grey, unfriendly place for a young man far from home! And there is some lingering whiff of the Council's disinfectant...

Friday, 28 March 2025

WSS: Battle of Münzkirchen - March 1703

 Yesterday (Thursday) I hosted this little-known action; a post from last week included some pictures of the initial set-up. My Zoom opponent was David, and we used my Corporal John rules, of which David has had some limited experience previously.

 
Scene-setting photo shows part of the Austrian left wing; General Backer (a Lorrainer) in command of his brigade, just outside the village of Sankt Roman

Background - Briefing Note and OOB

Following the defection of the Elector of Bavaria to the side of the French king, the Holy Roman Emperor orders that attacks be made on Bavaria right at the start of 1703, to inflict punitive damage and to make it clear what repercussions might be expected.

Feldmarschal Leopold Anton von Schlick has been sent to seize control of crossings over the Danube and the Inn in the area around Passau. The Bavarians know all about this expedition, and the Elector leads a strong force to contest the area. The two armies more or less blunder into each other near Schärding.

The two commanders are regarded as being competent, and the forces are roughly equal. In Corporal John terms, the commanders each have a hand of 5 Command Cards, and an initial allocation of 3 Combat Cards. Capture of either of the villages of Sankt Roman and Shießdorf will result in 1 temporary Victory Point [this means that an army entering a village which it does not already hold will gain 1VP, and will be regarded as holding that village until the enemy enters it – it is not necessary to leave a defending force in the village – if a village changes hands, the temporary VP will be transferred across]. 8 VPs wins the day.

The forces are of very similar make-up – the Bavarians have 1 extra unit of foot, the Imperialists 1 extra unit of horse. Neither army is trained in platoon fire. The Bavarians have two elite units (Leibgarde and Leibgrenadiere), and three of the Austrian foot units have attached battalion guns.

Position at 8am is shown on the map. David chose to be the Elector of Bavaria, which meant that I was Feldmarschal Von Schlick for the day, and a dice roll decreed that I would go first.

 


Bavarian Army (Elector of Bavaria)                                (7 horse; 12 foot; 2 art; 5 leaders)

Arco’s Brigade (Generalmajor Graf d’Arco)

Arco Kürassiere (3 Sqns)

Costa Kürassiere (3 Sqns)

Monasterol Dragoner (3 Sqns)

Santini Dragoner (3 Sqns)

Weichel’s Brigade (Generalmajor Weichel)

Leibgarde (3 Sqns)(elite)

Weichel Kürassiere (3 Sqns)

Wolframsdorf Kürassiere (3 Sqns)

Brinkelhof’s Brigade (Generalmajor Brinkelhof)

IR Bettendorf (2 Bns)

IR Haxthausen(2 Bns)

Boismorel Grenadiere (1 Bn)

Leib Grenadiere (1 Bn)(elite)

1 field battery

Maffei’s Brigade (Generalmajor Marquis de Maffei)

IR Lützelberg (1 Bn)

IR Kurprintz (1 Bn)

IR Maffei (1 Bn)

IR D’Octfort (1 Bn)

IR Spilberg (1 Bn)

IR Tattenbach (1 Bn)

1 field battery

 

Imperial Army (Feldmarschal Leopold von Schlick)       (8 horse; 11 foot; 2 art; 5 leaders)

Niederhammer’s Brigade (Generalmajor Niederhammer)

Alt-Hannover Kürassiere (3 Sqns)

Cusani Kürassiere (3 Sqns)

Gronsfeld Kürassiere (3 Sqns)

Aufseß Dragoner (3 Sqns)

Stoltz’s Brigade (Generalmajor Stolz)

Jung-Darmstadt Kürassiere (3 Sqns)

Lobkowitz Kürassiere (3 Sqns)

Leibregiment zu Pferd (Hessen-Kassel)(3 Sqns)

Spiegel Karabiniere (Hessen-Kassel)(3 Sqns)

Furneburg’s Brigade (Generalmajor Furst von Furneburg) [3 units have battalion guns]

IR Alt-Salm (1 Bn)

IR Gschwind (2 Bns)

IR Palffy (1 Bn)

IR Thürheim (2 Bns)

1 field battery

Backer’s Brigade (Generalmajor Von Backer)

IR Lothringen (3 Bns)

IR Scharfenstein (2 Bns)

1 field battery

 

A narrative of sorts should emerge from the pictures.  

 
Right at the start, Schlick was concerned about the artillery battery which was exposed on his right, so he ordered up Niederhammer's cavalry brigade to cover the flank - Arco's Bavarian cavalry responded, and brought on a desperate cavalry fight which swung back and forth throughout the day. View is from behind the Bavarian flank

 
Here you see it from nearer the ground - Arco with the cuirassiers in the foreground

 
General view of the centre, early in the day, from behind the Elector's lines

 
The Bavarian right flank, looking towards Schießdorf. Weichel Cuirassiers on the left of the picture, then the elite Leibgarde (in light blue)

 
Opposite them, the Austrian left surrounds the village of Sankt Roman

 
Counter-battery fire is rarely very effective in these games, but the Bavarians certainly had the edge on this day - here the Austrian No.2 battery is immediately getting lumps knocked out of it by the Bavarian guns across the valley

 
General view from behind the Austrian left, around 9:30 - things quiet apart from artillery fire at this end and the mad cavalry scrap in the distance

 
...as you see - Aufseß dragoons in the right foreground, helping out - it was a feature of the battle that the dragoon units in the cavalry performed pretty well

 
Bavarian centre, with central heating radiator

 
Backer still waiting for orders, a situation which lasted most of the day. Unit on the right of the picture is the 3-battalion IR Lothringen, also known as the Bishop of Osnabrück's Guard, which is always welcome on the miniature battlefield because their green uniforms provide a bit of welcome variety [these are ex Eric Knowles troops]

 
And still the cavalry battle between Arco and Niederhammer continues - red-coated Bavarian dragoons looking a bit exposed here, but they did quite well

 
Now some helpful cards present themselves, and the Austrian centre pushes forward

 
The Bavarian Bettendorf regiment has a moment to prepare itself for the onslaught...

 
...before the Austrian Gschwind lads arrive and punch a hole in the Bavarian line - this looks like a critical moment

 
[meanwhile] Maffei's Bavarian infantry are undisturbed by the drama to their left...

 
...and the situation is saved by the Bavarian Leibgrenadiere...

 
...(here in close-up)...

 
...and General Brinkelhof, with the Haxthausen regiment, which quickly routed both battalions of Gschwind. Situation stabilized, but some big gaps in the centre now

 
Still the cavalry on the flank are hard at it, and the Bavarians are showing a lot of damage

 
Some new spaces in the centre...

 
In the wood you can see Feldmarschal Schlick in person [please note] bringing forward the Imperial Regiment Thürheim to attack the Bavarian grenadiers

 
At this point the cavalry fight ended in the Austrians' favour, as Arco was seriously wounded, and the Costa cuirassiers were finally routed from the field. The Victory Points score was now 9-6 to the Austrians, 8 being required for overall victory


 
Here is a little study of the Bavarian Santini dragoons...

 
... and the Bavarian Red Grenadiers - the Boismorels - with Lt Col De La Colonie in command, thinking up a positive spin to put on his regiment's performance in his memoirs

 
The Elector (without hat) begins the job of organising a retreat

 
Final stand-off in the centre

 
Close-up of 1st Bn IR Thürheim, complete with their battalion gun. This is another ex-Eric unit, though I supplied the command figures

 
And the official scoreboard shows 9-6 to the Empire - tell the auditors

 
Since the scoreboard is not visible through the Zoom cameras, we also have an extra scoreboard on the table. The coloured counters are bonus VPs for holding the villages


My thanks to my worthy opponent - as ever, it was a close game - there were moments in the centre late on when either side could have suffered a major collapse. No problems with the rules, except that the Command Cards allowed us to leave the Bavarian right and the villages pretty much untouched. I forgot to drink my Lucozade, so I must have been busy.

 
 Time to get tidied up - General Backer finally gets the order, late in the evening, to tell his brigade to stand down. It seems that his side won...

 

 


Monday, 24 March 2025

Charles Creed - links restored

 It came to my notice that a post I put up here in May 2011 was no longer working, since the video links had expired. I believe I have now repaired the original post, so if you would like to have a look at some old Pathé movies about Charles Creed's military collection, you should find them here.

 


 

Saturday, 22 March 2025

Setting Up a Battle for Next Week

 I was supposed to get started on this a couple of nights ago, but I got hit with a letter from HMRC (the UK tax office) - the sort of letter which says "whatever you were going to do for the next few days, you'd better forget it and start panicking - we think you may owe us money from 5 years ago...".

In fact it is my mother who may owe them money, but the implication is the same. I have managed to write back, scrambling the ball back into their court, offering a polite Fact Check on their calculations. Thus things are peaceful enough again to get on with setting up a battlefield for the end of next week. Ruin can arrive in its own time.

This will be the little-known battle of Münzkirchen, from the early days of 1703, when the Austrians and Bavarians were suddenly on opposite sides of the WSS, and were worried about their common border, in the area around Passau.

All I have on offer this evening is a few photos showing general views of the table - there should be some actual fighting on Thursday.

 
General view from behind Bavarian left flank

 
This is Arco's Bavarian cavalry brigade, on their left - two units of cuirassiers and two of dragoons

 
A look along the Imperial army, from its right

 
Austrian horse - Niederhammer's brigade, on their right flank

 
Now a general view from behind the Bavarian right

 
The Austrian left and centre

 
Austrian cuirassiers - this lot are the regiment of Jung-Darmstadt

 
More of the same - these are Lobkowicz's boys


 
One of the Bavarian cavalry commanders, Weichel, leads his men onto the field
 

 

Sunday, 16 March 2025

Hooptedoodle #475b - Garden Project [3]

 Least unexpected post of the year? Big day here yesterday - long, heavy shift.

I took the opportunity to photograph various areas of improvement since the start of this year. Some of this may not look like much, but it is a massive change after what has basically been more than 2 years of neglect!

 
The hedge extension is in place and standing firm

 
It's even lined up nice and straight. Some removal of tree roots from the old juniper was needed to free up the planting trench

 
This and the remaining photos are of the tidying up and mulching of various beds; this one is where the old leylandii was (the one which blew down in a gale) - discussion is taking place about hedging and maybe some feature shrubs

 
Backside of the front hedge - a prodigious amount of ivy, brambles and general rubbish has been removed

 
We have rescued our beloved white lilac, which was smothered in ivy

 
Tulips and primulas showing signs of life

 
The stump in the middle of this bed is the remains of a 75-foot eucalyptus, which was removed in about 2008

 
Some pointing of the patio is needed, but that is currently Priority 2 - if not 3

 
This bed was a complete wreck, with kerria and bamboo spreading about 6 feet out from the fence. This is more like it - we'll re-seed the bit of the lawn which got discouraged. We also found the rhubarb plant we got from Uncle Louis, years ago - haven't seen it for a while!

 
This is a quick shot of the notorious Back Vennel - now it can be accessed without special equipment. More work to be done here, but one thing we found was the base of a clematis, which is our plant but grows entirely in our neighbour's garden - we may need to sort something out here