Yesterday I hosted/umpired a "distanced" game, featuring - nay, starring - Stryker as Wellington and nundanket as Massena - lofty company indeed. We used my Ramekin variation on C&CN, on a 17 x 9 hex table, and the forces were scaled to about 60% of the original, just to get everything on board (so to speak).
I spent some time studying the available scenarios - and eventually constructed my own. Some challenges for Fuentes - it is a very big battle, by Peninsular War standards, but also rather an odd battle in some ways. I chose the 3rd day (which, confusingly, for me, was the second day of fighting - the battle was 3rd-5th May, and the 4th was mostly spent manoeuvring, while Massena tried to come up with something rather more clever, and Wellington extended his right flank, in anticipation of this more clever thing which Massena might do). The great, received British traditions of this 3rd day are mostly surrounding the early morning action, when Montbrun's cavalry and Marchand's and Mermet's divisions of VI Corps made a left hook through forests and swamps, and flushed Houston's 7th British Division out of the village of Pozo Bello. Craufurd was sent with the Light Divn and some cavalry support, to rescue the 7th Divn - Houston managed to retire to Freneda, which is to the west of the main battlefield, and took no further part. Craufurd then undertook a celebrated withdrawal, with his infantry in square, and with gallant support from his outnumbered cavalrymen. This section of the action is also famous for Norman Ramsay's "charge" with a couple of guns from the RHA, and so on - if you want a truly dramatic account of all this, Napier is your man, though how accurate the depiction is may now be a topic for discussion.
Whatever, I reluctantly decided that much of this early-morning caper is splendid stuff, and would lend itself beautifully to a big game of Sharp Practice or similar, but is far too tactical and fiddly for a big game with a blunt instrument like C&C. Thus our game started with Houston gone and Craufurd on his way back - I would have to grit my teeth and do without the Brunswickers and Chasseurs Britanniques, and our field would have Pozo Bello a mile or two off the south-west corner.
The game, then.
This is my rather basic version of a C&C set-up plan.
Start: general view from north-east corner - Anglo-Portuguese on the right, town of Fuentes (worth 2 temporary Victory Points to the French if and while they hold both hexes of the town) right in the middle of the photo
Start: looking along Wellington's main line, from his right - those big Foot Guard battalions look impressive, but they had a quiet day...
Start: view of the Allied right flank, with Craufurd's force strung out across the field, and Montbrun's cavalry appearing through the trees from the direction of Pozo Bello. Below you see Fuentes itself, with the garrison looking across the river towards Ferey's Divn [I substituted fords for the original bridges, just to avoid that annoying and rather undignified business of balancing sabots on the handrails]
Start: Beyond the Allied left, you see Ferey, with support from the Divns of Conroux and Claparède - the counters on the table edge are further battalions which are still to arrive - Drouet D'Erlon kept back part of the IX Corps force as a reserve. The river is shallow, but the section in the foreground (from the wiggly bit) is in a gorge, and unfordable.
Start: The French centre, with Montbrun's cavalry, Marchand and Mermet beyond. The centre was intimidated by the Allied artillery facing them (for once, the French are outgunned), and served mainly to pin Wellington's main force, and limit the extent to which the Fuentes town position could be reinforced.
Start: Drone shot of Montbrun's cavalry, making a fairly dismal job of harrassing Craufurd. The Allies won the first initiative roll of the game, which was a good one to win
Right from the beginning of the action, the fight for Fuentes began, and it was as bloody as Napier says; to everyone's amazement (especially Massena's), the French gained immediate success and took the southern end of the village. They were promptly driven out again, but came back with equal success. The theme was set - this was the main area of fighting for the day - very quickly, the French were 3-2 up in VPs (9 needed for the victory). Ferey is #17 - he had a very active day.
General view, about an hour into the game. Not much happening in the centre, though the 6eme Léger are taking a bit of a bashing from the artillery.
And still the fighting goes on at Fuentes - I really did lose count of the number of times it changed hands. At this point, the French brought up a battalion of grenadiers (red counter), but they didn't do very well.
On the French left, Montbrun sends a regiment of dragoons up, forcing the 52nd Foot into square, but they were seen off by Slade with the British 1st Dragoons.
Unusual sight - Montbrun's two dragoon units take shelter in the woods - the official story was that this was to clear the way for more troops and the French horse artillery.
Still not a lot happening in the centre, though the French had now pushed one of their own foot batteries forward, where they provided good support for the troops holding Fuentes.
More troops crossing the river, and still the situation at Fuentes is half held by each side, and heavy fighting.
Under the claim that Massena was having problems with his old injury from Essling, I took the opportunity to field him in a carriage. He looks peaceful - he may, in fact, be asleep. The young ADC in the white hussar kit is the Marshal's 17-year-old son, Prosper, who is definitely very wide awake.
The French now have both bits of the village, so the 2 bonus VPs are shining on the scoreboard, and Picton brings up some Portuguese troops to try to do something about it.
The British dragoons attack - and defeat - the French dragoons in their wood - never seen one of these before...By this stage, with the IX Corps chaps coming up in support, it is becoming obvious that Wellington is not going to be able to do much about recovering the town; his supporting units on that flank are already badly battered. From memory, I believe the VP count was about 7-3 at this stage, so something desperate was needed from the Allies.
General view after about 3 hours fighting - the French hold the village, and Wellington's troops on the high ground are a lot more sparse than they were.
Wellington leads a general advance in his centre, to inflict some losses on the French troops opposite, and to cut off the Fuentes position.
General MacKinnon, who commanded the area around the town, was seriously wounded in the fighting, and Picton became personally involved in the effort to recover the position - here he is attached to some of the Portuguese from Powers' brigade, who are obviously nearing the end of their day.
Here is General Claparède, of IX Corps, leading some of his men against Fuentes town. I took a great affection for the General, whose name is obviously really Clapper-'Ead (his family were bell ringers). Round about this time the 79th Highlanders, after a long and arduous fight, were finally eliminated, and the French had won 9-4. Someone went to wake up Massena and let him know.
As ever, thanks to my colleagues for their courage and enthusiasm - sitting watching a big battle on a laptop requires not a little fortitude and stamina, so I appreciate their efforts very much! I very much enjoyed my day umpiring and watching fake history come to pass, and it was terrific to have someone to talk to!
Wow, what a struggle! Looks like a thoroughly enjoyable experience was had by all (apart from the little chaps around Fuentes de Onoro that is). Love Massena in his carriage - maybe you can get a miniature of the Madame X in her dragoon uniform to share it with him. She could even be worth a VP of her own, I imagine he would have valued her company highly enough to warrant that!
ReplyDeleteYes, it was good - we had quite a lot of problems with Zoom dropping out, but I got really good at reconnecting the session - could have done without this, though. An interesting effect came as a result of my fitting some new 2600 lumen LED bulbs (2 of them) to the overhead lamps. When you are in the room it is excellent - appreciably brighter, and it looks sunny. Through Zoom, though, the cameras in my tablet and my iPhone both corrected the picture, so it was actually darker. Best results came from dimming the lights a bit! I'm sure I can find something in the device settings, but it was a surprise!
DeleteMme X (Dubreton?) - I just know that Andreas at Art Miniaturen would be delighted to sculpt a suitable figure in 1/72 - sadly, I can't afford him!
It was a great game Tony, thanks again. I should point out that Wellington himself was in the thick of things risking life and limb but sadly to no avail (and the Foot Guards behaved very well too!).
ReplyDeleteYes indeed - Wellington was exposed to enemy fire at the end - praiseworthy, though there was a French rumour that he was trying to die in action (unfair!). Before the game, I had visions of the French abandoning the hopeless task of capturing the town, and instead crashing on the rock of Stopford's Guards Brigade, who would certainly take some beating. However, it was not to be, which just go to show how much I know about these things. Thanks for playing, Stryker - a gallant showing!
DeleteA great wave of peace and contentment swept over me as I read this with my morning cup of coffee, Foy. It's a joy to see your lovely troops in action, and what an exciting game. I love your Massena by the way!
ReplyDeleteThank you, WM - what exactly were you smoking with your coffee btw? Yes it was very pleasant to have a Zoom day - it is a weird way to spend time, but if it helps interraction with other people then I'm all for it.
DeleteIt was a bit indulgent to have Massena in a carriage, I admit it, but the carriage has only ever been on a battlefield twice before, so it's worth a shot. All the best WM - keep well.
I didn't want to mention my 'special cigarettes' in front of your young and impressionable audience, Foy, and besides, we've just had a rather unfavorable referendum about it.
DeleteHuffety puffety, Ringstone Round. If you lose your hat it'll never be found.
DeleteFine battle spectacle, Tony! I enjoyed your Fuentes de Onoro very much especially your frequent drone shots. Those aerial photos really help to place the action. Tougher fight than expected for the British. Losing the 2VPs at FdO early-on may have compromised the English defense.
ReplyDeleteGreat stuff as always. In a virtual game, with you as ringmaster, you must have been hopping from one side of the table to the other.
A speeded-up recording of my umpiring performance yesterday would have been exhausting to watch - probably quite funny for a little while, too. With my bigger table set-up, I had placed one end of the board against the dresser, so circumnavigation (circumparambulation?) became impossible, and I had to always change sides at the non-dresser end - this was OK - I think I have the hang of this now. Another aspect was that the troops were often more than half-way across the table from their base-line, so the Allied turn would often require me to nip round the other side to move their cavalry, for example. All good stuff - I should have worn a pedometer. Absolutely essential in one of these games to keep everything tidy, to put each activation counter away as soon as it has been used - I'm actually relying on these counters to keep me right on where we are up to - the visiting generals were kind enough to join in with spotting stray dice and counters for me - I did lose 3 carry-forward order counters for the Allies at one point (I put them back into my pocket instead of the ramekin pot - sloppy...), but Wellington spotted it, since he knew how many counters he should have (you don't suppose the sneaky devil was keeping notes...? - in fact, I know he was, and it was a great help. Keeping notes is good.
DeleteThis was a great game to participate in. The scenario is a real challenge - Tony managed to find the germ of a really good game in a sprawling battle. I would have looked at the historical maps and thought "how the hell do you get that onto the table top?" given up and moved on to something else.
ReplyDeleteThe French never had full control of Fuentes until late on in the game; were promptly kicked out before taking it all back again. Take those 2 points off and it's still all to play for. If you can see all the white counters on the French units, several were on the brink of being converted to VPs for the Anglo-Portuguese.
By the way, I'm taking credit for the first innovation in Napoleonic tactics in over 200 years. Dragoons in woods. Worthy of the Emperor himself. ;-)
Have those grenadiers be converted to a pioneer battalion yet?
Well played Young Sir. The fighting around Fuentes developed in a strange way - at first the French were doing rather well just to get a toe-hold in the village, then that bounced back and forward for a while, then it became obvious that the French were probably going to hang onto those 2 bonus VPs, and that Wellington was suddenly very short of fresh troops to support his left flank. Prior to that, I could have imagined the 2 bonus VPs disappearing (which would have brought it back to 5-3 or so), the French losing a couple more worn battalions and the whole thing swings back again. The French IX Corps infantry could have had difficulty getting up to the front quickly (the off-table reserves might be expected to have "Out of Command" problems, since their Divn commanders were forward, fighting for the village). As you say, a few of the French battalions were in poor shape by the end.
Delete9-4 looks like a resounding win, but for most of the game it looked as though it could level up. I also expected the French infantry to lose a few attacking Wellington's centre.
Anyway, as I say - well played! I wonder what would have happened to Massena's career if this had been the historical result? Was FdO Massena's last battle? I don't think he was required for Russia. If he'd been kept on I'm not sure how things would have developed.
As I mentioned yesterday, while scratching together the scenario I was impressed by how similar the set-up for the battle was to Albuera, which I played twice over the last year or so - French frontal assault on a town (on a river) supplemented by a left hook and a corresponding extension of the Allies' right, the front of battle being turned through an angle. That was an especially idle ponder on my part, but it did seem to have some similarities. The battle itself, of course, was completely different!
The combined grenadier battalion had a disappointing day, as you suggest, but, as we know, a lot of the British eye-witnesses claimed they had been fighting the Old Guard (they didn't have René North uniform cards in those days), so they could blame someone else.
A most enjoyable account of a great looking game! Fuentes d'Onoro is a challenge for both sides with many options and challenging terrain. A wonderful representation of the battle Tony. Your generals both made a great show of it!
ReplyDeleteRegards, James
Thank you James - it was fun. The visiting generals did especially well, not just to rise to the occasion so handsomely, but also in coping with my pathetic stream-of-consciousness blather for a few hours. Such men are born, not made.
DeleteFantastic stuff! I suspected the town would be hard-fought for, so it clearly turned out - and how!
ReplyDeleteBloodbath, old boy - bloodbath. You may imagine how angry the French troops were when they found that the chocolate orange minis were no longer there.
DeleteExcellent battle report - of course the wrong result but it seems Wellington just ran out of steam.!
ReplyDeleteOne of my favourite battles that is a challenge for both sides.
You’ve done well again umpiring this to a successful conclusion
Thanks Graham - these games aren't exactly frequent at the moment, as you know, so I try to set them up nicely!
DeleteMagnificent stuff Tony...
ReplyDeleteAn entertaining read and a joy to behold...
I have also noticed the amount of exercise one gets from multiple circuits of the wargames table during virtual games... I can think of worse ways of keeping fit.
All the best. Aly
Thanks Aly - it was altogether a grand day in! It does reinforce my preference for umpiring these Zoom games - I can handle the running about and not dropping the toys, but I might struggle if I also had to think what I was doing if I were commanding one of the armies!
DeleteI really enjoyed the photos and narrative of this game, Tony! Fuentes was indeed his last battle, and his last command (Massena was tired, and had definitely NOT wanted another command anywhere after the 1809 campaign, least of all in Spain!).
ReplyDeleteThanks Peter - poor old Massena lost his edge very quickly, it seems - he was never the same after somebody or other (hush) shot his eye out on that hunting trip...
Delete