As discussed in
my last post, the real Siege of Newcastle makes an uncomfortable basis for a game, since it was really two separate events with a sort of extended hangover period between. I have now produced a fudged version of the history, which gives a better excuse to stage a proper siege. The scenario is now some weeks earlier than the real event, and the garrison of Newcastle seems to have been augmented by some returning veteran troops who, in complete defiance of accepted history, did not fight to the last man at Marston Moor, but marched off back home at the first opportunity, just squeaking over the bridge into the town before the Scots captured Gateshead and slammed the - erm - gate.
To get round the further issue that the Scots' best strategy appears now to be to wait and starve the town into submission, I've also applied some political and contextual reasons for them to have to get on with taking the place.
I think it will be all right. The game will take place on Wednesday - I shall have one guest general taking the part of the besieged, the other the besiegers, and I shall be the umpire. That may sound nastily as though I will actually play a solo game, with two slaves to help, but I shall take care to ensure it doesn't work like that. The three of us will - collectively - play through our version of the Siege of Newcastle - if it turns out that the town never stood a chance then the process should at least be educational. If it turns out that the rules don't hang together very well then we can agree to patch them on the fly. It's all in an excellent cause. And there will, of course, be some supper.
I've managed to reduce my multiple attempts at siege rules (9 years of false starts, plus numerous manuscript scribbles - some actually jotted down while away on holiday) to a single typed document - well, all right, a mature draft - I still have a little time to check to see if some of the numbers need to be altered to give a balanced game. I have also produced three documents, to set the context for our game. I have one each for the two commanders, telling them what they, personally, need to know, and I have a general preamble, which I shall include here, which sets out the (amended) historical situation in terms which are common knowledge - stuff which can be freely shared.
I'll publish the specific notes for the two commanders, and the OOBs, along with the game report - these chaps are quite crafty enough to check for secrets on my blog...
Here goes - this is the first handout - both commanders get this as a starter.
Preamble
(general knowledge, issued to both commanders)
It is 8am on Monday 3rd October
1644. It is a dreary, cold morning – blustery, with the threat of rain later.
The scene is the area outside the walls on the northern side of Newcastle upon
Tyne, an important coal and commercial centre with a population of about 11,000.
Newcastle has been loyally supportive of King Charles throughout the first two
years of the Civil War. It is a bleak landscape – not enhanced by the presence
of many small, abandoned coal workings and the burned-out ruins of some humble suburbs
that had grown up outside the town’s Newgate and Pilgrim Street Gate, destroyed by the garrison to clear the field of fire from the walls.
The town of Newcastle has had varying
numbers of Scottish Covenanter troops stationed outside it (their HQ is at
Elswick) since they arrived in February, at which time a demand for surrender
of the town was refused. Rather than commit time and effort to a major siege,
the Scots then marched south to Sunderland, leaving a small force to watch Newcastle.
The main objectives of this campaign were always York and the main Royalist
field armies.
Since then the Battle of Marston Moor has
taken place in Yorkshire (2nd July), which was a massive defeat for
the Royalists and in which the Scottish army was heavily involved. Shortly
afterwards the important Royalist city of York surrendered. The King’s
situation in the North is now desperate – with the exception of isolated
garrisons at Pontefract, Carlisle, Durham, Newcastle and a few other places,
there is no prospect of the Royalists re-establishing any significant level of
control, thus their focus is increasingly centred on holding the city of
Chester, which is an important port on the other side of the country and
controls access to North Wales.
The great champion of the King’s cause in
the North, William Cavendish, Marquis of Newcastle, who almost single-handedly
raised and financed the Royalist effort in the North-East, has now gone into
exile in Germany, largely as a consequence of Prince Rupert’s having
successfully shifted the blame for Marston Moor onto his shoulders. He and almost all his
field army are lost to the Royalist effort – a major blow.
The Scottish troops, under Lord Leven, have
now returned to finish the business at Newcastle itself. Apart from its role as
the last major Royalist port in the North-East, Newcastle is an essential
supplier of coal to Parliamentarian London – restoration of the London coal
supply is seen as the main deliverable from capture of the town, and Leven is
now under a lot of political pressure to take the place, and quickly.
The situation in Newcastle is now critical
– though an effort has been made to collect supplies into the town, the arrival
of a fresh Scottish force under the Earl of Callander resulted in the capture
of the town of Gateshead (27th July), on the other end of the only
bridge over the Tyne, and of the fort at
South Shields, at the mouth of the river, so that the town is now cut off from
the outside world for the first time – prior to this, despite a supposed
Parliamentary blockade, some ships had been taking coal to Rotterdam and
Hamburg, and returning with provisions and armaments.
Leven arrived back at Elswick from
Yorkshire on 15th August with his main army – the Scots have now
constructed pontoon bridges across the Tyne both upstream and downstream from
Newcastle, and hold the south bank of the Tyne – the port and castle can now be
fired on from across the river. They have troops and guns all around the town.
There has been an extended exchange of
diplomatic letters between Leven and Sir John Marley, who is both Mayor and
Military Governor of Newcastle. Leven has been urging for speedy surrender, to
avoid unnecessary loss of life (and to protect the coal supply!), and Marley
has deliberately been prevaricating and nitpicking over the protocols under which
terms should be agreed, and about whose fault it will be if bloodshed does
occur. Marley’s obvious aim is to play for as much time as possible, which
seems odd since there is no chance of being rescued by any kind of relieving
force.
Leven is known to be subject to much
criticism in London for what is perceived as a dilatory and otherwise unsatisfactory
showing at Newcastle. There is also a widespread feeling that, after a long and
illustrious military career, he is now too old for the stresses of campaigning
- even his most loyal colleagues fear this may be true. Throughout the
protracted game-playing of Marley’s supposed negotiations for terms of
surrender, Leven has intermittently carried out some limited bombardment of the
town, but it seems to have been more to emphasise his overwhelming advantage
than to destroy the place out of hand.
Leven has a total force of perhaps 20,000
soldiers, stationed on both sides of the Tyne and all around the walls of
Newcastle. The obvious site for batteries to breach the walls is on the ridge
at The Leazes, which faces the medieval town wall between Newgate and Pilgrim Street
Gate. The walls of the town have been repaired, but they are of an archaic
style which predates siege artillery, and there are no earthworks to protect or
support them against roundshot.
Marley’s total force is unknown, but it
cannot be more than a couple of thousand. He has recently sent a couple of
sorties out in the vicinity of the Sandgate (off the table – outside the town
on the riverside, to the east) which went surprisingly well, they caused some
casualties, upset the Scots and took a few prisoners. Scottish morale seems
surprisingly low…
Separate Topic
The Contesse has been sorting out her folders of photos, and she found this rather scary exhibit - I never knew such a picture had been taken, though I shall be on my guard in future. Apparently this was almost exactly three years ago - obviously on a dark and stormy night. In the intervening period, both the sofa and my sweater have gone to the landfill, it seems (you can see why), but the fierce concentration and the Silence of the Lambs magnifying "jeweller's loop" (which I occasionally wear when answering the door, just to frighten the mailman) are still very much in evidence. I had a half-hearted attempt to see if I could work out what I was painting, but didn't get very far.
As you can probably see, one of the difficulties I have in painting is that my nose is too long to allow me to get close enough to the job. As you can also see, one of the advantages of this hobby is that you don't always have to look your best.
