Yesterday I had a visitor here at the
Chateau. My good friend Goya came, to give his Austrian army a first run out,
and we took the opportunity to try the Commands & Colors Expansion #5, Generals, Marshals and Tacticians, with
its amended set of Command cards, which has been sitting undisturbed since it
arrived some months ago.
I have never been involved in a miniatures
game involving Austrians at any time since I started wargaming 200 years ago,
so I put a lot of thought into drawing up a scenario, such as would grace the
auspicious occasion. Since the Austrian force, though growing quickly, is still
rather small for one side of a C&CN game, we chose a format where the Kaiserlichs would be defending a strong
position against a considerably larger French force, and we chose Eugène
Beauharnais’ campaign in Northern Italy in 1813-14. This is suitable for Goya’s
late-war uniforms, and it meant that we could use my Spanish/Italian buildings without too much embarrassment.
Research revealed that, apart from Dr GF
Nafziger’s invaluable volume on this campaign, there is almost nothing in the
English-language history books. David Chandler glides seamlessly from
Leipzig/Hanau to Brienne, F Loraine Petre includes a single paragraph (to the
effect that Eugène was pretty much banished to the Army of Italy because the
Emperor had “had enough of his stepson’s incapacity”), and the Elting &
Esposito atlas has an arrow pointing off the main map of 1813, indicating that
Eugène was over here somewhere, facing the Austrians. The reason? – quite
simple; neither Napoleon nor Wellington was present, so who could be
interested?
I found some Austrian sources in Google
Books, but overall was surprised at the paucity of material. I finished up with
an action at the mythical village of Bassaro, not far from Ferrara (or possibly
somewhere else), which apparently commanded a couple of important crossings
over the River Adige. The timing, the location and the personnel are not
dissimilar to the action around Castagnaro, so there is a rough whiff of
authenticity about some of what we were doing. Thank you, yet again, Dr
Nafziger.
So Goya’s Austrians were installed in
Bassaro and its environs – there were some very important-looking generals
present, one of whom had a passing resemblance to Archduke Charles, but they
were there only as observers – the Austrian commander on the field was
Generalmajor Sutterheim, assisted by Generals Stahremberg, Eckhardt and Wrede
(no – not the Bavarian). They had available the 9th Jäger Regt, the Gradiscaner Grenzer Regt, the infantry regiments Kerpen, Bianchi and Jellachich, the Grenadier battalions Purcell and Welsperg and two 6pdr foot batteries, supported by the Radetzky Hussars and the Dragoon
regiments Savoy and Hohenlohe – that’s a total of 7
battalions (two of which were light infantry), 3 cavalry units and 2 artillery.
Austrians have a few national
characteristics in C&CN. The line infantry battalions are big – 5 blocks –
and have the unique ability to adopt a
solid square formation (Bataillonmasse) against cavalry, which behaves like a
normal square as far as the rules are concerned, but does not require a Command
card to be held hostage on the Square Tracker. The line infantry and the
Grenzers suffer double retreats if things go against them, otherwise things are
pretty much standard C&CN – troops firing on the move have the half-effect
rounded down, and there are the usual advantages for light troops and
grenadiers.
Their opposition for the day came from the
Division of General Marcognet, who had the French infantry brigades of De
Conchy and Jeanin (both names familiar to me, as these were distinguished battalion
commanders from the Peninsula) and the Italian brigade of St Paul (another old
friend), with, between them, a total of 14 battalions, of which 4 were lights,
and there was also a cavalry brigade comprising 2 French regiments of Chasseurs
à Cheval and some Italian dragoons, and an Italian foot battery and a French
horse battery.
I, of course, was Marcognet, since it was only
right that Goya should command his shiny new army. Scenario specifics were that
each commander had 5 Command cards and an initial hand of 3 Tactician cards,
and that 7 Victory Points would decide the day. There were extra VPs available to
the French for each village hex they occupied, and for each of the bridge and
the 2 fords which they held. If things became too difficult to hold the
position, the Austrians’ only retreat was over the river by this same bridge or
the fords (the river being otherwise out of bounds), and they could reduce the
French VP holding by 1 for every 2 units or leaders they retreated off the
table – such units and leaders could not return, but they would not count as
VPs for the French. The only other rule of the day was that any unit which
spent an entire move on the road – starting and ending their move upon it, and
not involved in any combat – could have an extra hex of movement. In the event
neither the road nor the extra VP rules came into play.
To set up, the Austrian commander could
place his units anywhere in his half of the table (including the centre line).
Having seen the initial defensive position, the French commander could place his
entire army within 3 hexes of his baseline – for both armies, leaders could be
placed with units if desired. Thereafter, the Austrians could move 3 units or
leaders, the French could then move 2, and – finally – the Austrians could move 1 –
still restricted to their own half. At that point, we dealt the cards, and the
French started the first turn.
My plan, such as it was, given my big
superiority in infantry and the cover provided by the central ridge, was to
march my main force over the ridge in as much mass as I could manage, overrun the
batteries, punch through to the west (my left) of the village and attack the
fords. Meanwhile, the French light infantry would advance through the woods to
demonstrate against the bridge. The Italians and the cavalry were in reserve on my left, the
intention being that they would pile into the attack on the fords as support
for the main attack.
The tricky bit was making the extra numbers
pay off before I lost enough troops to fulfill the Austrian victory
requirements. It was obviously going to be messy, but it seemed possible. A quick mass advance in the centre, shielded
from artillery by the ridge, started things off well, but after that it got
progressively more disastrous.
First thing is, these big Austrian line
battalions have a lot of firepower, and the double retreats never counted for
anything, since I didn’t manage to dislodge anybody. Beyond that difficulty,
it’s all down to me. The advance in the centre was delayed by lack of suitable
cards, true, but also because I had been too cautious with the deployment of my
general officers – if I had been braver, and attached them to the leading
units, a couple of cards turned up which would have used their
presence to speed up my attack. I also made a mess of the placement of my light
infantry, so that the attack through the woods made very little progress – I
wasted a lot of time trying to pull battered units out of the way so that they
could be replaced by fresh ones, and it all took too long – the bridge was
never threatened. When the main attack did reach the central ridge it was
disjointed and had little cohesion, the Austrian infantry were ready and used
bonus cards well to maximise their fire effect.
Elsewhere – on my left – the Italians were
a poor relation, since I could never spare enough orders to get them properly involved.
My cavalry was outmatched by the Austrian heavies (my Italian dragoons melted
away like snowballs in Hades) and, as a result of a stupid miscalculation of
move distances for the cavalry, an otherwise inspired pincer attack with my
mounted troops failed dismally and also cost me the Italian artillery.
Drat.
In the end, I just ran out of men – the
Austrians achieved their 7 VPs and the day was lost – I still had enough troops left to threaten the village, but it had all been too slow, and I had
not managed to hold the line together well enough for the units to provide the
mutual support which is necessary to stop them falling back.
A most enjoyable day – my compliments and
thanks to my noble opponent, not least for driving an hour and a half out here to
the Front of Beyond with his precious troops. After a fairly slow start we did,
in fact, get the bloodbath I feared we might. The lesson was familiar, but
clear – attacking in Commands & Colors is a challenge, especially if you
are timid with your positioning of leaders, and if the cards refuse to
co-operate with your Grand Scheme.
Great fun!
 |
The battlefield, viewed from the northern (Austrian) side - the village of Bassaro
nestles in a bend of the River Adige - the fords can be seen on the table edge |
 |
| Things get under way - French on the left, Austrian Jägers in the woods near the bridge |
 |
French left - the cavalry promised little and delivered less, though the brigadier
led a charmed life, and they managed to leave the Italian battery exposed with predictable results |
 |
| Sutterheim sorts out his defence |
 |
Marcognet makes heavy weather of his advance at the far end, while the
Italians and the cavalry wait for their moment at this end |
 |
As the Command cards played out, a couple of general officers with the French advance
would really have got things going much quicker - oh well... |
 |
Stirring sight - the Austrian cavalry performed excellently, including a couple
of successful bonus (follow-up) melées which did a lot of damage [please
ignore any Spanish unit titles on the borrowed sabots] |
 |
Grenzers in the woods - they had a fine view of the cavalry proceedings, but
otherwise were not called upon to do very much |
 |
At this point, Marcognet's attack was already going badly - the single unit on the
ridge should have been four units all supporting each other - there will be questions asked... |
 |
This was as far as the attack through the woods got - too late, and the Austrians
(noted for their famous bridge balancing act) had organised enough firepower to
prevent anyone emerging from the trees |
 |
| This looks like a lot of troops, but the boys with all the casualty markers are being withdrawn |
 |
This photo captures a point at which the main, central attack has started to fizzle out,
and the cavalry scrap is about to start |
 |
| ...and here it begins, with the French horse outmatched and in any case unable to combine properly |
 |
| So much for the cavalry - Marcognet has one last push in the centre... |
 |
| ...but the Kaiserlichs are ready, and Victory Points are mounting up! |
 |
| Another view of the end of the day |
