Napoleonic & ECW wargaming, with a load of old Hooptedoodle on this & that
Thursday, 3 March 2016
Hooptedoodle #211 - Like Icarus, ascending on beautiful, foolish arms
I read somewhere, recently, someone describing someone's written output (not mine, I hasten to say) as a stream of the uninteresting, enlivened here and there with brief moments of the inconsequential. It occurred to me that my Hooptedoodle folio must get precious close to just this, but - since I have a certain house standard and tradition to maintain - I feel I should persist with the current editorial policy.
Today's Pointless Post is merely to note the quick passing of a coincidence - a wow, just fancy that moment which is unlikely to distract you from your day's purpose nor tax your belief set. These things happen, after all.
I have been doing a lot of reading about sieges in the English Civil War, at least some of which is directed towards developing a workable siege game. One of the sieges I am about to come back to is the Leaguer of Chester.
When I'm reading the history of battles, campaigns and so on I very much benefit from having a decent map to hand - I seem to be unusually bad at visualising a geographical area without such an aid - there have been many occasions, reading on the bus of Napoleon's adventures in Saxony, for example, unable to unfold Loraine Petre's flaming maps, when I have nodded stupidly at a bewildering list of German villages in the narrative, and tried to ignore the fact that I have once again completely lost the plot. So one of my bits of preparatory work for my continuing siege research was to find some decent maps of Chester online, and print a couple off. I found, and printed off, this one
which dates from 1580, and is not ideal, since it predates the siege and thus shows none of the relevant details, but is a good start.
Now I have been having a tidying-up session this week, and I felt that it would be a good idea to put my printed map somewhere safe so that I can use it when I get back to reading the Chester stuff (probably next week). My splendid idea was to fold it and put it inside my favourite Chester book, John Barratt's The Great Siege of Chester. The bad news is that I will never possibly remember where I put it, but the good news is that I might get a pleasant surprise next week when I open the book again. You know how these things work.
So I opened the Barratt book to store the map, and - purely by chance - the book fell open at exactly the same map. I didn't even know the map was reproduced in that book. OK - the limited subject range obviously has a big effect on the probability, but what were the chances of that? Would you take me on at any dice game on such a day? Should I break with tradition and buy a lottery ticket?
Nah. It was just an isolated fluke. There will be another one along soon, and it will probably be just as useless.
Almost certainly.
In passing, just for a bit of fun, my post heading is supposed to be an oblique reference to flying pigs (a British euphemism for a very unlikely event) - can anyone tell me where the quote is from? If it helps, it isn't Icelandic - no, I didn't think that was helpful either. [If you solved it using Google you are a tosser, by the way.]
Monday, 29 February 2016
The Realism Paradox - a thought for today... and yesterday
In yesterday's post I made reference to some siege game rules which appear in Appendix 3 of Christopher Duffy's wonderful Fire & Stone - The Science of Fortress Warfare 1660-1860 (Peters, Fraser & Dunlop - London, 1975). I've been re-reading this book recently, along with its "prequel" for the period 1494-1660, which was published some 4 years later.
At the beginning of this same Appendix 3 there is a paragraph which made me chuckle. Nowadays the views expressed would not be regarded as reactionary or even particularly controversial, but the loss of direction within the wargaming hobby which is described here has a lot to answer for - for me, certainly. In this paragraph is the very thing which forced me into a 10 year sabbatical, which explains my periodic ebb and flow of enthusiasm - maybe even why I have mostly done my wargaming on my own, away from fashions and from know-alls. I wish I'd read and understood this around the time it was published - I shall certainly keep it handy as a reminder now. All those games which would not and could not ever end - how much would you like the time back now?
The original, recreational spirit of wargaming is preserved among civilian and military enthusiasts who have devised rules which enable them to re-fight battles and campaigns of any period in the past. Unfortunately the codes of regulations even in the amateur game have become so elaborate that the participants spend more time in making their calculations and arguing among themselves than in moving their pieces. Thus a re-fought Waterloo or Gettysburg often proves to be hardly less acrimonious than the original version, and the sense of the rapid passage of time - one of the most vital elements of "realism" - is frequently lost altogether.
Christopher Duffy 1975
Sunday, 28 February 2016
More Siege Topics
I now have work in hand to produce
effective trench sections, after some years of just thinking about it, and also
to fabricate support pedestals to allow troops to man the city walls when their
bases are deeper than the walkway – all clever stuff, but this will require a
little while to produce something worth looking at.
In the meantime, I have been tinkering with
some new pottery houses (all right – ornaments, if you must) which seem to be
shaping up nicely to form a 17th century town centre, and – since I
had the brushes out – I have finally eliminated those ghastly red roofs from my
Eco castle.
I had been offered a wide range of advice –
I’ve been urged to leave it alone, or completely repaint it, or do something in
between, so I have produced a good British compromise – I’ve left most of the
castle unaltered, and have repainted the roofs and touched in the windows to
clean them up a bit.
I have also painted the swimming-pool
coloured moat section under the drawbridge – it is now a charming shade of mud,
and I poured in my new-and-trendy Decoupage medium, which – in theory – should set to form
something looking like water. This last step isn’t looking too promising at
present – the medium contains a surpising quantity of bubbles. The received
wisdom is that these should disappear as the medium dries, but they do not seem
to be doing this – which may be related to the fact that the medium does not
appear to be drying.
Oh well – it may all turn out wonderful. If
not, I assume that the medium will dry eventually in some form or other, and if
necessary I can repaint and varnish or whatever. Let’s wait and see. I refuse
to be pessimistic about it.
| Down in the street in 17th century Chester, or some such place? |
| Just a glimpse of how this might look, with the old citadel looming in the background |
Back to the pottery houses – these are the OOP
Britain in Miniature series, by Carol
Tey, who produced them in Norfolk for a while. Not all the range is suitable,
but a few of the items are a useful size, and have a nice, stylised (almost
playful) look which I think goes well with toy soldiers. They are, it goes
without saying, my usual underscale mismatch with the 20mm figures, but they
look OK (it also goes without saying). It is a dreadful thing to admit, but I
am carefully applying matt varnish to these Tey houses – it improves the look
enormously, though it would very much upset serious collectors. I have picked up
these pieces very cheaply on eBay. It amuses me that the range is such that my
besieged town is likely to contain a very high proportion of British tourist
sites – all in one small area – Chester’s Rows, Ann Hathaway’s cottage, a
number of inns and historic guildhalls from Norfolk – I even have my eye on
John Knox’s house, which should fit in well, and no-one will notice…
Maybe.
One thing that this book certainly brings home is the dreadful loss which the demise of Gallia miniature buildings represented - there are many photos of Gallia fortress pieces and so on, in both 25mm and 15mm and they are - well, fantastic, actually. I've never seen such a thing on eBay - this book was published 1990 - I have no idea when Gallia ceased production - anyone know?
Thursday, 25 February 2016
Hooptedoodle #210 - Jim and Ike and the Cowhouse
From time to time I post here what I consider some of the
more entertaining tales by which my family commemorate our quirkier ancestors.
I’ve grown a little wary of doing this, since some of the comments I’ve
received make it pretty clear that the authenticity of these stories is a
matter of some doubt, that the tales are sometimes thought to be faked for the
viewing audience.
Not so. If I had the strength or the moral fibre I would
protest – I might even expostulate, if I knew how. If I had the imagination to
invent this stuff I would be quietly pleased. This does not preclude the simple
possibility that a bunch of lies has been handed down the family over the
years, of course, but, though the tales may have been polished in the
retelling, I believe they are substantially correct. Anyway, here’s another one…
Now then. Let’s go back just a little. Great Grandfather
George was my father’s father’s father (which is a straightforward idea, if
tricky to say), and he was a moderately wealthy market gardener (vegetable
farmer) near the small town of Rainhill, in Lancashire. He was a tenant farmer,
and his business was run very efficiently by his wife Ellen, who was not a
local woman – she came from somewhere further south – possibly Gloucestershire,
as I recall.
The big problem was George’s thirst. Things got to a point
where he would set off with his horse and cart all loaded up, on a Saturday morning,
to take the produce to Warrington Market, and the horse would bring him back on
Sunday, drunk and penniless. Every rum-pot in Warrington knew where to cadge a
drink if George was in town. He was a celebrity, of a sort.
![]() |
| Brickmaker's Arms public house, Warrington, c1900 |
![]() |
| Warrington workhouse - old George is in an unmarked grave somewhere here |
![]() |
| A Liverpool milk-float - not Ellen's - the Anfield Dairy looks rather up-market |
![]() |
| Toxteth - c1900 - not very rural - this is Wilson Street, at the Dingle |
![]() |
| ...and here is a supper bar in St James St |
![]() |
| More like the thing - Willaston Village, Wirral, around the same date - Jim had a smallholding at Nine Acres, not far from here |
Jim knew for certain that any stranger who came near his
farm was up to no good. One weekend he intercepted the collective gentry of the
local hunt (yoicks!), who were crossing his land, and told them that if he saw
them again he would shoot them. They dismissed him airily, as you would expect,
and two weeks later he fired a shotgun during a hunt, allegedly at them, and
was arrested. He spent a little while in prison, and then some time in a mental
institution.
When I knew him he was over 80, I guess, and I was a very
small child – if I had started school then I had only just started. Jim was
long retired - he gave up the farming,
basically because he was always too lazy to make any money. He then lived in a
council flat at Knotty Ash, Liverpool, which was many miles from our house, yet
for a while he regularly visited us around teatime on a Saturday – my dad used
to buy fish and chips for our weekend treat on Saturdays, and Jim was more than
happy to drop in, unannounced, and share. He always claimed that he had just
been passing, but a journey from Knotty Ash on the tram was a lengthy
undertaking, requiring much planning. He used to come via the Saturday market in
Garston, where he used to purchase crazy gifts for me – once a plaster figurine
of an Alsatian dog, daubed with gold paint, often a bundle of pencils which
only had about an inch of lead in each end, and once a framed picture of the
Pope (cut from a magazine) – interesting in their way, I suppose, but each of
them a poor swap for a decent plate of fish and chips.
Jim and Ike both had telephones installed in their homes –
neither had many friends, and they kept in constant touch by means of this new
technological wonder. I was once in my granddad’s house when he was on the
phone to his brother, and I remember that they both shouted so loud that I
thought they could simply have opened the window and communicated without
involving the telephone service. Like a lot of retired men of their era and
their background, they sort of lost their way a bit, having no useful role in
the community. Ike was desperate to fix stuff, to repair things, to be useful
and respected.
He repaired a handbag of my mother’s, and it was about twice
as heavy after he had fixed it, the new leather patches contrasted strangely
with the original material, and it would not open properly. It went in the bin.
He agreed to fix Jim’s alarm clock, which had stopped
working. After he had got it working, he quizzed Jim on why it had been so
rusty – he had had to strip down and hand-polish all the internals with oil and
carborundum paper – a lengthy job. When Jim explained that it had fallen in his
chamber pot one night, Ike said he was a dirty bugger, and they didn’t speak to
each other for some weeks.
Ike’s worst ever repair job was when my Auntie May brought
back a delicate silver bracelet from Spain – from the first foreign holiday any
of that family ever went on (if you ignore Uncle Les’s time in Tunisia and
Italy in WW2). He thought it looked disappointingly flimsy, and offered to
improve it for her – this involved very large blobs of extra solder at every
joint, and Auntie May was heartbroken, though it was definitely stronger – Ike
was getting a bit past it by then, if that is an admissible defence…
Jim lived on his own in his flat in Knotty Ash, and he got
very frail and very dotty. He still insisted on riding his bicycle, to
everyone’s despair, in spite of frequent blackouts. On one occasion a motorist
found him lying in the road, helped him up and stood him up in a shop doorway
to see if he was all right – Jim punched him because he felt that the motorist
must have knocked him off his bike. I believe that may have been the end of
Jim’s cycling.
For a while my father used occasionally to travel on his
Lambretta scooter (125cc) to visit Jim, to see how he was getting on, and
invariably found him to be cheerful, full of energy and completely bats.
He was
making a fried breakfast one Sunday when my dad arrived, and Jim invited him to
share it, though there were no plates – the idea was they would both eat from
the frying pan, since this saved on the washing up. Needless to add, the frying
pan was never washed either. He also offered my dad some homemade bread to go
with it – he said that he had become very keen on baking, which he thought was
doubly useful since it kept his fingernails clean. My dad declined this
splendid offer. Uncle Jim asked my dad (who was, like his father, an electrical
man) to have a look at his radio, which hadn’t worked for a while. Apparently
it was a real museum piece – Jim hugged it and pressed his ear to the silent
speaker – he said that he was sure there was still life in it (actually, he
referred to it as “him”), and that he had heard “him” speaking sometimes when
he was in the other room. My dad swore that Jim had a length of wire from the
EARTH (ground) terminal on the radio chassis, and the other end was in a
plant-pot full of soil from his yard – I’ve never been sure about this – it
sounds too much like an Irish gag.
![]() |
| Lambretta 125, just like my dad's - that pillion seat was not recommended for long distances - I still walk with a limp |
Ike had a severe stroke when he was about 75, and died
within a couple of days, but he died secure in the proud knowledge that he was
something of a local rarity, since he owned his own house (he had bought it
with the £500 he inherited from the sale of his mother’s dairy), and that he owned
the first TV set in his street; they had bought it so the neighbours could
watch the (1953) Coronation on it. Since he already had a telephone that he overcharged
the neighbours to use, this was the ultimate in Beating the Joneses. My
granddad was quite big-time – as a foreman in the electrical workshop, almost
unbelievable nowadays, he used to wear a waistcoat and a bowler hat. My lasting
childhood memory of him is sitting in his armchair, resplendent in waistcoat
and silver watchchain (which I have somewhere), with the cufflinks and
detachable starched collar removed from his work shirt, slurping a cup of tea.
Jim was well into his eighties when he died – his end was
unfortunate, solitary, and in some ways had a lot in common with his life. He
was boiling eggs on his gas stove in his little flat when he seems to have had
some kind of dizzy turn. The coroner’s inquest reckoned that the pan of water
boiled over, extinguishing the gas flame, and Jim was gassed while he was
unconscious.
That’s enough about that lot. I also might add, in passing,
that I have a relative from a different branch of the family, who was gaoled in
the 1970s for spying for the Russians – this is absolutely true, by the way. I
think I’m probably not allowed to say anything about this story, so I’ll leave
it for the moment. Just saying.
Things could get worse.
Sunday, 21 February 2016
A Weekend Miscellany...
![]() |
| The Gothenburg, Prestonpans |
On Saturday I drove through to Prestonpans (yes - that Prestonpans), which is just down the road from here, to attend the Scottish Battlefields Wargames Show, which was staged upstairs in the Gothenburg pub. I was there early, since there had been concern that the small venue and the lack of parking space might by a problem - in fact, unless it picked up later, the attendance may have been a bit disappointing. Nice little show - there were a number of appropriately themed games, including some in which visitors might take part. I think there were about 7 trade stands, and maybe the same number of demonstrations, so there was a pleasant intimacy about the proceedings.
| I liked this 10mm version of Flodden, presented by the Glasgow Wargames people, who - as always - were affable and enthusiastic and patiently informative |
| Some of the 10mm unsung heroes of Flodden |
| Supreme Littleness - for those who have yet to be convinced about MDF... |
I took very few photos in Prestonpans, not least because I wasn't really speaking to my camera at the time, my confidence having been shaken somewhat by Wednesday's problems.
I got home to find that the postie had delivered my last two fortress components - a couple more gates, on which I have now daubed paint in the house style, so that they may take their place in the FORTS box.
| One on the left is from JR Miniatures, the other is by Kallistra |
| The Covenanters get a pretty clear run at the hill, if they can just get through that pesky stream... |
| ...and the capture of East Boldon didn't take long - more wet feet |
| General view, from the Royalist side, with the Scots getting their assault organised |
| Last effort from the King's horse, with Sir Chas Lucas about to be laid low for his trouble |
| Another general view, Scots on the left, just before the end |
Thursday, 18 February 2016
ECW - Boldon Hill, 24th March 1644
The initial positions can be seen in the previous post. To start off similarly to the original action (though rather earlier than teatime), Hew Fraser's Dragoons began with a hesitant attack on the fields surrounding the hamlet of East Boldon, and they were driven off rather easily by Royalist musketeers lining the hedges - the dragoons took no further part in the action.
The Royalist horse started very aggressively, in the more open ground wide on the right flank, and caused their Scottish equivalents a lot of trouble and some serious damage, but the cavalry action, as often happens with these games, was pretty much self-contained - the infantry battle developed slowly, more or less unaffected by their mounted colleagues. The Scottish foot advanced steadily and effectively up Down Hill (yes, all right) to attack the Royalist line, and successfully brushed away some troublesome artillery. They also occupied East Boldon village, but the second line which was supposed to be following in support was delayed and rather disorganised trying to get across the stream in the bottom of the valley.
After a vicious exchange of musketry on the hillside, the Covenanters took the victory by a margin of 9-7 in Victory Banners - this was helped greatly by the Royalists' late loss of two general officers - Lucas and Eythin were both wounded.
Close thing - could have gone either way (once again), and the game completed in around two hours, which is not bad at all considering that my opponent had no previous experience of the rules. I very much enjoyed the first wargame I've staged for a while, and I believe that I have not frightened away my guest general - I've added him to my list of potential volunteers for forthcoming events, including (if I get it organised) some possible siege work.
I'm sorry this is a rather unambitious report - I seem to have had some problem with my camera last night, and I got very few useable pictures.
Monday, 15 February 2016
ECW - Boldon Hill - The Set-Up
Painting and varnishing of buildings is now ended, and the dining room is now set up for the Battle of Boldon Hill (24 Mar 1644), which is scheduled for Wednesday evening. Because I can't count, I dug out one extra regiment of foot for the Royalists and - since it seems a pity to put them away again - I've added them to the OOB.
The view in the photo is facing almost due south - the Earl of Leven's Covenanters are on the left, the Marquis of Newcastle's Royalists on the right; the villages (which still exist today) are, left to right, Cleadon, East Boldon (with adjacent farming enclosures) and West Boldon (complete with St Nicholas' Church). To put a geographical fix on this, the Covenanters have the North Sea behind them, the ground beyond the right-hand edge of the table drops away past Hylton Castle to the River Wear, and the town of Sunderland is some miles beyond the opposite far corner of the table. There may, of course, be some minor tweaking of initial unit placings before we start.
The nice shiny stream (the Don Burn) is finished with brush-on decoupage medium, which I haven't tried before, but which does the job with no hassle.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)












